Welcome to Carroll Gardens

Carroll Gardens is a picturesque Brooklyn neighborhood known for its leafy streets, iconic brownstones, and strong sense of community. Combining old-world charm with modern conveniences, it’s a serene, family-friendly enclave nestled just minutes from the buzz of Downtown Brooklyn and Manhattan.

A neighborhood with Italian roots and small-town charm

Carroll Gardens offers a rare blend of history, culture, and neighborly warmth. Originally settled by Irish and Italian immigrants, the area still retains much of its old-world character. Stroll down the wide streets, and you’ll spot immaculate brownstones with lush front gardens (a rare sight in Brooklyn), Italian bakeries, and generations-old businesses that give the neighborhood its soul.

It’s not uncommon to hear the ring of church bells or to stumble upon a local block party or street fair. With its intimate feel and beautifully preserved 19th-century architecture, Carroll Gardens feels like a village in the heart of the city.

Fun Fact: The neighborhood’s name comes from Charles Carroll, a signer of the Declaration of Independence, and the distinctive “gardens” in front of homes required by 19th-century building codes are now a hallmark of the area.

Cost of living

Carroll Gardens is among the more sought-after and premium neighborhoods in Brooklyn, with a real estate market that reflects its desirability. A one-bedroom apartment rents for around $3,800 to $4,200/month, while classic brownstones and townhomes can command prices ranging from $2.5 million to $7 million, depending on size and condition.

Despite the cost, many are drawn by the neighborhood’s quiet streets, exceptional schools, and tight-knit community vibe. It's a true investment in lifestyle.

Career opportunities

Living in Carroll Gardens means being just minutes from Downtown Brooklyn, the Financial District, and Midtown Manhattan ideal for professionals in finance, tech, law, education, and healthcare.

Closer to home, the neighborhood supports a vibrant small-business economy, with opportunities in retail, hospitality, and entrepreneurship. Carroll Gardens also attracts creatives and freelancers who enjoy working from home or one of the many cozy cafes lining Court and Smith Streets.

Cultural landmarks that define Carroll Gardens

• St. Mary Star of the Sea Church: A beautiful Catholic church that has served the community since the 1800s.
  
  

• Carroll Park: A beloved community hub featuring playgrounds, basketball courts, and summer movie nights.
  
  

• Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary–St. Stephen Church: A striking structure and a symbol of the area’s Italian heritage.
  
  

Restaurants and shops

Carroll Gardens is a haven for food lovers. Its dining scene is rooted in Italian tradition but has expanded to include global flavors and trendy eateries:

• Lucali: A legendary pizzeria where people line up for hours to taste what many call the best pizza in NYC.
  
  

• Frankies 457 Spuntino: A Carroll Gardens staple offering rustic Italian fare in a cozy, garden-backed space.
  
  

• Court Street Grocers: Known for gourmet sandwiches and curated grocery goods.
  
  

• Caputo’s Bakery: A family-run Italian bakery serving fresh bread and pastries since 1904.
  
  

Shoppers will enjoy the mix of independent boutiques, vintage shops, artisanal markets, and specialty stores that line Smith and Court Streets.

Public transportation

Carroll Gardens offers excellent transit access with the F and G subway lines serving the neighborhood, getting you to Manhattan in just 20–25 minutes. Many residents also enjoy biking or walking to nearby neighborhoods like Cobble Hill, Red Hook, or Gowanus.

Find your dream home in Carroll Gardens

If you’re seeking classic Brooklyn elegance, welcoming neighbors, and a peaceful lifestyle with city access, Carroll Gardens is calling. The Martin Eiden Team is here to help you navigate the neighborhood’s competitive housing market and find your ideal home in one of NYC’s most beloved enclaves.